Difference between revisions of "B3-Demonstration character of the project"

From Iess
Jump to: navigation, search
m (→‎EFFORTS FOR REDUCING THE PROJECT'S "CARBON FOOTPRINT"discuss (max. 10.000 characters))
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
==DEMONSTRATION CHARACTER OF THE PROJECT(max. 10.000 characters)<sup>[[Talk:{{PAGENAME}}|discuss]]</sup> Note: for forests monitoring projects this box should not be filled in==
 
==DEMONSTRATION CHARACTER OF THE PROJECT(max. 10.000 characters)<sup>[[Talk:{{PAGENAME}}|discuss]]</sup> Note: for forests monitoring projects this box should not be filled in==
 +
The demonstration character of the LIFE IESS proposal plays along two dimensions: a vertical dimension that goes from citizens to higher institutions, and an horizontal dimension that mainly links citizens and smaller towns across different places in Italy and Europe.
  
−
The COWS project will be a full-scale application of integration of co-digestion of WWTP sludges and OF-MSW, including prototype pre-treatment separation technology to obtain highly mixable slurry.
+
Along the vertical axis, IESS demonstration starts with citizens for citizens: persons active in the project implementation demonstrate to other citizens that joining forces and resources to reduce the environmental burden returns benefits also in the short time.
 +
These citizens give evidence also to the skepticals in the council that their engagement improves the effectiveness of public investments and amplifies its reach.
  
−
The demonstration character of the project focuses on three different aspects: (1) demonstration of the feasibility of COWS on a full scale level, (2) demonstration of the cost efficiency and time efficiency of COWS and (3) demonstration of the environmental benefits of COWS .
+
Smaller town councils on turn are more accountable to citizens and improve their credibility toward upper authorities (provinces and regions) being able to give evidence of the effectiveness and the short time needed to trigger positive snow-ball effects with the bottom-up approach put in place by IESS. This helps then to articulate better the local needs in the planning of upper level. This capacity of demonstration should ease the match between bottom-up and top-down flows.
  
−
During the last part of the project in Action B4 two main activities will take place that enhance the demonstration character of COWS:
+
In fact, to the actors of top-down mode, typically Regions and Provinces, the project provides a demonstration of a greater capacity to contribute and of a better quality of contributions in terms of detection of problems and proposed solutions, and also for the effective implementation of top-down planning in a way taylored to territories shapes.
−
* the accumulated experience and know-how will be elicited and organised ih a handbook that aims at facilitating the evaluation and implementation of COWS solution
+
 
−
* during the demonstration run it will be possible for interested professionals and decision makers to see the functioning of COWS process in "showcase mode" which means that all adjustments and modification issues as well as the functioning and replication of COWS pre-treatment prototype unit may be examined in-depth.
+
Regarding the horizontal dimension, the demonstration character of the project can have a direct and immediate impact for other small cities and towns of the Veneto Region and can attract other municipalities and small Italian communities through dissemination and networking actions.
 +
 
 +
However, the most important horizontal level is the European network of small towns through which the aim of the project is to provide a model and a concrete experience to be shared, examined, revised, improved and replicated. The project is carried out at the scale of the three municipalities involved in the territory (Medio Brenta area in the Padua Province, Veneto Region, IT) but can be easily extended and exported to other areas in Italy and in other European regions.
 +
 
 +
IESS demonstration has also a thematic character, focused on 4 main showcase themes: mobility, land, energy and water in a comprehensive set of micro projects co-operating to strengthen the resilience of the territory and to develop a systemic and pro-active approach to climate change at local level.
 +
 
 +
Even if at a local dimension, the implementation of several organic measures may also steer a shift in the environmnetal governance paradigm and have direct impacts on CO2 reduction also within the time-frame of the project.
  
 
==EU ADDED VALUE OF THE PROJECT AND ITS ACTIONS<sup>[[Talk:{{PAGENAME}}|discuss]]</sup> (max. 10.000 characters)==
 
==EU ADDED VALUE OF THE PROJECT AND ITS ACTIONS<sup>[[Talk:{{PAGENAME}}|discuss]]</sup> (max. 10.000 characters)==
−
COWS put in practice a demonstration of an innovative solution for upgrading existing sludge treatment plants while improving the effectiveness of OFMSW handling.
+
The LIFE IESS proposal addresses precisely climate change environmental objectives of EU importance, contributing to “the adaptation and increased resilience of the EU economy and society, nature and biodiversity, water resources and human health to the predicted impacts of climate change and mitigating its impact”.
  
−
Potential users of this solution are more than 30.000 similar facilities in Europe.
+
The IESS concept grounds on the European environmental policy framework: Europe 2020 Strategy, White Paper Adapting to climate change: Towards a European framework for action, COM(2009) 147 final, EC, Connecting climate knowledge for Europe, SEC(2011) 1254 final) and on most recent suggestions at international level about climate change adaptation and mitigation strategies and bottom-up approaches  (ICLEI, UNEP).
  
−
COWS  Project addresses directly the achievement of regulatory and legal compliance with environmental objectives of EU importance, contributing and enabling the implementation of the Water Framework Directive, the Urban Wastewater Directive, the Waste Directive and the  Waste Water Sludge Directive.
+
The proposal’s main goal is to design, initiate and demonstrate a bottom-up strategy - aggregating and integrating the resources of partner municipalities - to support the development of climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies and action plan al local scale, in accordance with one of the priorities of the LIFE+ 2012 call (Climate change theme).
  
−
COWS addresses also the pillars of Europa 2020 on the side of reducing environmental pressure from waste and improving the capacity to exploit energy production from renewable or quasi-renewable sources.  
+
The IESS Project also encourages the implementation of solutions and approaches demonstrated as viable, including specific actions to ensure that it can be replicated, with the necessary adjustments, in other European smaller towns and local communities.
 +
The IESS Project foresees a great involvement and consultation of stakeholders during all the project implementation process.
  
−
The effort of COWS to make available a handbook for its replication will help the enforcement of EU waste legislation and best practices.
+
Along with the horizontal demonstration feature goes the construction of stronger links with other European communities, hence contributing to add value at EU level.
−
Moreover it will contribute to preparatory works in view of better collaboration for coordinated enforcement of water and waste framework directives  by water utilities and waste management utilities together updating their practices to taking into account available technical solutions as that demonstrated in COWS.
+
 
 +
Partners agree that is necessary to reduce the gap between the European vision on climate change and that of the local communities, thus promoting cohesion and strengthening the concept of European citizenship. The concrete outcomes of the project can then be easily replicated on other territories with regional support. In this way, it is possible to decrease the levels of mediation without jeopardizing the concept of subsidiarity. On the other hand, a European-style approach also allows to bring EU environmental policy closer to local territories making it more concrete.
 +
 
 +
When conceiving the proposal, IESS partnership took also into account the option of developing the project with a transnational cooperation from the start. Our analysis shown that the effort to keep a real collaboration would have been disproportionate if included in the implementation,  while devoting a substantial attention to networking after having put in place the project would bring better results and higher added value.
  
 
==SOCIO-ECONOMIC EFFECTS OF THE PROJECT<sup>[[Talk:{{PAGENAME}}|discuss]]</sup> (max. 10.000 characters)==
 
==SOCIO-ECONOMIC EFFECTS OF THE PROJECT<sup>[[Talk:{{PAGENAME}}|discuss]]</sup> (max. 10.000 characters)==
 +
The costs of climate change for the Italian economy for the next century have been calculated correlating temperature increase with economic damages. In 2050, Italy would therefore suffer a loss equivalent to 20-30 billion € at current prices. This value would be six times higher in 2100.
 +
 +
These assessments, however, are likely to underestimate the real future cost of climate change, not only because they consider autonomous adaptation, but also because they do not include important non market impacts, such as biodiversity loss, or the loss of cultural heritage. (Carraro, 2008)
 +
 +
The socio-economic effects of the project must be considered by two different points of view
 +
*avoided risks,
 +
*immediate direct benefits.
 +
 +
Risk and benefits must take into account also other negative items.
 +
The avoided risks can only be estimated because we are referring to the major damage that would suffer the population and the territory in the absence of the measures envisaged by the project.
 +
 +
Some elements can already be considered: for example, the fitting of public maintenance activities and private waste-water management can actually help to prevent critical situations become serious. In these cases, vulnerable people will suffer more, and in fact they will be the ones who benefit most from the avoided risks.
  
−
During the implementation of COWS there will be a positive impact in terms of occupational effects both within the beneficiary organisation itself (between 3 workers and 2 technicians will be hired to work on the COWS plant) and on the side of the suppliers where it is expected some positive figures but which is not directly under the control of beneficiaries.
+
Another example is mobility. In unfavorable climatic conditions, for example in summer, the options of carpooling can help to reduce exposures to temperatures. The lack of traffic and noise can lead to an improvement of the general health of the children and the elderly.  
  
−
Other positive effects - possibly reached through dissemination activities and involvement of main stakeholders in preparatory actions - will be a growing social awareness about the positive impacts of the plant.  
+
A further aspect of avoided risks may also relate to the indirect effect of early detection triggered by the project activity that has a profound value of alert and sharing. From this point of view the only drawback might be the effect of slipping down of the interventions from above  in the scale of priority. For example, in an emergency situation, the assistance could be diverted to priority or areas actually less equipped.  
  
−
There is increasing awareness that the total amount of municipal solid waste is continuously rising. Not so for the the problem of sewage sludge which seem to be less understood as an environmental problem by the average citizen. Showing the figures of the solution brought about by COWS is possibly a deterrent to the NIMBY effect, given that the facility is already there and the project transforms it in a power-generating plant instead of being a flare-torch exhaust.
+
This issue is something that is simply to be taken into account and that is part of the “price” to pay for the improvement of a proactive capacity.
−
This will help realizing that the tons of solid waste and of sewage sludge to be safely disposed without any negative impact to the environment are a part of the solution to the quest for energy in sufficient and sustainable amount as pre-condition for economic and social development.
 
  
−
COWS helps demonstrating that, depending on the way the energy is produced, it may contribute to environmental problems related to water, land and air pollution and global climate change.  
+
There are two types of immediate social and economic benefits produced by the project: (a) improvement of the conditions for those directly involved in the project, (b) benefits for the system.  
  
−
In the case of the COWS solution, luckily, there is the possibility, foreseen by the model itself, of building the plant inside an existing treatment facility located in a peripheral zone, with the only possible addition of traffic in the area. Moreover, the solution will not affect inhabited zones because the COWS plant is near a motorway interchange.
+
In social terms, immediate direct benefits to the individual are, for example:
 +
*improvement of the quality of service (improved mobility, better accessibility to the territory)
 +
*improvement of living conditions in terms of health (quality of air and noise are among the determinants affected)
 +
*improvement of psychosocial conditions
  
−
The design of COWS takes also account of the fact that the reception, storage and treatment stages all take place in a closed environment and with a slight depression of the atmosphere so as to reduce the fermentation odors of the OFMSW.  
+
At system level, the project triggers an improvement of general social conditions as a result of the interaction and collaboration created during its implementation, that can become a shared method to be extended to other fields of application.
  
−
Lastly, the point should be emphasized that, though indirectly, for citizens the "COWS effect" could mean savings on their waste disposal bills in the long run.
+
On the economic front, direct immediate benefits for individuals ranging from personal savings (eg in the case of mobility in which the costs can be shared) to a decrease of the cost of the energy bill (eg in the case of micro-projects on energy, alternative energy sources or energy savings), from a better quality of agricultural produce (and / or supply in case of a food subsistence system) to the improvement of the effectiveness of the results - in the presence or not of a cost reduction  (eg with maintenance projects and other micro-interventions in the water sector).  
  
−
The economic impact of the project is twofold.
+
In terms of systemic economic benefits, as always very difficult to estimate, there may be a “territorial marketing effect”: it is certainly more attractive to settle in a cohesive territory than in other places. A potential advantage is that an area of this type will have a greater awareness and environmental monitoring capabilities and thus attract more economic activities that look favourably on their relationship with the local context. For example, the economic activities linked to the short food supply chain or those linked to the local environmental capital (ecotourism).
−
* the investment for the implementation of COWS acts as a leverage that increases local economy.
 
−
* There is a long term economic effect which is related to increased effectiveness on running costs for the community.
 
  
−
The economic balance of the project shows that each year there will be an improvement of operational costs in the order of 400.000 EUR.
+
Another potential long-term economic benefit is the reduction of lock-in phenomena; sharing from the bottom-up of intentions and future plans allows to detect entanglements early - before any investment is made.
 +
 
 +
Bibliography:
 +
* Carraro, Carlo, 2008, “Cambiamenti climatici e strategie di adattamento in Italia. Una valutazione economica” FEEM in collaboration with the Institute for Environmental Protection and Research Istituto Superiore per la Protezione e la Ricerca Ambientale - ISPRA)
  
−
During COWS implementation a specific action will be devoted to monitor and assess this impacts (please see Action C3).
 
  
 
==EFFORTS FOR REDUCING THE PROJECT'S "CARBON FOOTPRINT"<sup>[[Talk:{{PAGENAME}}|discuss]]</sup> (max. 10.000 characters)==
 
==EFFORTS FOR REDUCING THE PROJECT'S "CARBON FOOTPRINT"<sup>[[Talk:{{PAGENAME}}|discuss]]</sup> (max. 10.000 characters)==
  
−
Beneficiaries believe that efforts to keep project's carbon footprint low should focus on:
+
Beneficiaries believe that efforts to keep the project's carbon footprint low should focus on:
−
 
 
 
* projects management activities;
 
* projects management activities;
 
* implementation actions;
 
* implementation actions;
 
* content of the project.
 
* content of the project.
  
−
From the management point of view the COWS Project will adopt an internal code of conduct to reduce its carbon footprint.
+
From the management point of view the Project will adopt an internal code of conduct to reduce its carbon footprint.
−
Fortunately partners' offices are located in the same neighborhood.
 
  
−
Moreover, the use of printed flysheets, proceedings, and data collections will be strongly limited. Regarding specific communication materials, only the parts of the Layman's report, leaflets and some posters will be printed on recycled paper.
+
As the Partners' offices are located in the same neighborhood, the project's mobility will be informed to the principle of exemplarity.
 +
Transportation will be minimized, with the exception of the trips that involve activities to be eventually carried out on European territory (exchange and visits with other networks and projects).  
  
−
Transportation will be minimized, with the exception of the trips that involve activities to be eventually carried out on European territory (exchange and visits with other networks and projects).  
+
The use of printed information materials will be limited to essential. Regarding specific communication materials, only the parts of the Layman's report, leaflets and some posters will be printed on recycled paper.
  
−
On implementation actions, "greening clauses" will be included in procurement contracts, following the guidelines already in place at SEARIS, SEAAMB and COMVIA (and improving them if possible).
+
On implementation actions, "greening clauses" will be included in procurement contracts, following the guidelines already in place (and improving them whenever possible).
−
 
−
On the content of the project carbion footprint reduction is a key target, accounting for more than 1,450 TCO2/year and 400 TOE per year saved when COWS will be fully operational.
 
−
Similar figures would be spared for each COWS-like upgrading of existing anaerobic sewage sludge treatment plant. 
 
  
−
Pictures (If you wish to add a table or a picture, save it as an image file and upload it)
 
  
  
 
[[index:LIFE|Torna all'indice]]
 
[[index:LIFE|Torna all'indice]]

Latest revision as of 21:53, 22 September 2012

DEMONSTRATION CHARACTER OF THE PROJECT(max. 10.000 characters)discuss Note: for forests monitoring projects this box should not be filled in[edit]

The demonstration character of the LIFE IESS proposal plays along two dimensions: a vertical dimension that goes from citizens to higher institutions, and an horizontal dimension that mainly links citizens and smaller towns across different places in Italy and Europe.

Along the vertical axis, IESS demonstration starts with citizens for citizens: persons active in the project implementation demonstrate to other citizens that joining forces and resources to reduce the environmental burden returns benefits also in the short time. These citizens give evidence also to the skepticals in the council that their engagement improves the effectiveness of public investments and amplifies its reach.

Smaller town councils on turn are more accountable to citizens and improve their credibility toward upper authorities (provinces and regions) being able to give evidence of the effectiveness and the short time needed to trigger positive snow-ball effects with the bottom-up approach put in place by IESS. This helps then to articulate better the local needs in the planning of upper level. This capacity of demonstration should ease the match between bottom-up and top-down flows.

In fact, to the actors of top-down mode, typically Regions and Provinces, the project provides a demonstration of a greater capacity to contribute and of a better quality of contributions in terms of detection of problems and proposed solutions, and also for the effective implementation of top-down planning in a way taylored to territories shapes.

Regarding the horizontal dimension, the demonstration character of the project can have a direct and immediate impact for other small cities and towns of the Veneto Region and can attract other municipalities and small Italian communities through dissemination and networking actions.

However, the most important horizontal level is the European network of small towns through which the aim of the project is to provide a model and a concrete experience to be shared, examined, revised, improved and replicated. The project is carried out at the scale of the three municipalities involved in the territory (Medio Brenta area in the Padua Province, Veneto Region, IT) but can be easily extended and exported to other areas in Italy and in other European regions.

IESS demonstration has also a thematic character, focused on 4 main showcase themes: mobility, land, energy and water in a comprehensive set of micro projects co-operating to strengthen the resilience of the territory and to develop a systemic and pro-active approach to climate change at local level.

Even if at a local dimension, the implementation of several organic measures may also steer a shift in the environmnetal governance paradigm and have direct impacts on CO2 reduction also within the time-frame of the project.

EU ADDED VALUE OF THE PROJECT AND ITS ACTIONSdiscuss (max. 10.000 characters)[edit]

The LIFE IESS proposal addresses precisely climate change environmental objectives of EU importance, contributing to “the adaptation and increased resilience of the EU economy and society, nature and biodiversity, water resources and human health to the predicted impacts of climate change and mitigating its impact”.

The IESS concept grounds on the European environmental policy framework: Europe 2020 Strategy, White Paper Adapting to climate change: Towards a European framework for action, COM(2009) 147 final, EC, Connecting climate knowledge for Europe, SEC(2011) 1254 final) and on most recent suggestions at international level about climate change adaptation and mitigation strategies and bottom-up approaches (ICLEI, UNEP).

The proposal’s main goal is to design, initiate and demonstrate a bottom-up strategy - aggregating and integrating the resources of partner municipalities - to support the development of climate change mitigation and adaptation strategies and action plan al local scale, in accordance with one of the priorities of the LIFE+ 2012 call (Climate change theme).

The IESS Project also encourages the implementation of solutions and approaches demonstrated as viable, including specific actions to ensure that it can be replicated, with the necessary adjustments, in other European smaller towns and local communities. The IESS Project foresees a great involvement and consultation of stakeholders during all the project implementation process.

Along with the horizontal demonstration feature goes the construction of stronger links with other European communities, hence contributing to add value at EU level.

Partners agree that is necessary to reduce the gap between the European vision on climate change and that of the local communities, thus promoting cohesion and strengthening the concept of European citizenship. The concrete outcomes of the project can then be easily replicated on other territories with regional support. In this way, it is possible to decrease the levels of mediation without jeopardizing the concept of subsidiarity. On the other hand, a European-style approach also allows to bring EU environmental policy closer to local territories making it more concrete.

When conceiving the proposal, IESS partnership took also into account the option of developing the project with a transnational cooperation from the start. Our analysis shown that the effort to keep a real collaboration would have been disproportionate if included in the implementation, while devoting a substantial attention to networking after having put in place the project would bring better results and higher added value.

SOCIO-ECONOMIC EFFECTS OF THE PROJECTdiscuss (max. 10.000 characters)[edit]

The costs of climate change for the Italian economy for the next century have been calculated correlating temperature increase with economic damages. In 2050, Italy would therefore suffer a loss equivalent to 20-30 billion € at current prices. This value would be six times higher in 2100.

These assessments, however, are likely to underestimate the real future cost of climate change, not only because they consider autonomous adaptation, but also because they do not include important non market impacts, such as biodiversity loss, or the loss of cultural heritage. (Carraro, 2008)

The socio-economic effects of the project must be considered by two different points of view

  • avoided risks,
  • immediate direct benefits.

Risk and benefits must take into account also other negative items. The avoided risks can only be estimated because we are referring to the major damage that would suffer the population and the territory in the absence of the measures envisaged by the project.

Some elements can already be considered: for example, the fitting of public maintenance activities and private waste-water management can actually help to prevent critical situations become serious. In these cases, vulnerable people will suffer more, and in fact they will be the ones who benefit most from the avoided risks.

Another example is mobility. In unfavorable climatic conditions, for example in summer, the options of carpooling can help to reduce exposures to temperatures. The lack of traffic and noise can lead to an improvement of the general health of the children and the elderly.

A further aspect of avoided risks may also relate to the indirect effect of early detection triggered by the project activity that has a profound value of alert and sharing. From this point of view the only drawback might be the effect of slipping down of the interventions from above in the scale of priority. For example, in an emergency situation, the assistance could be diverted to priority or areas actually less equipped.

This issue is something that is simply to be taken into account and that is part of the “price” to pay for the improvement of a proactive capacity.

There are two types of immediate social and economic benefits produced by the project: (a) improvement of the conditions for those directly involved in the project, (b) benefits for the system.

In social terms, immediate direct benefits to the individual are, for example:

  • improvement of the quality of service (improved mobility, better accessibility to the territory)
  • improvement of living conditions in terms of health (quality of air and noise are among the determinants affected)
  • improvement of psychosocial conditions

At system level, the project triggers an improvement of general social conditions as a result of the interaction and collaboration created during its implementation, that can become a shared method to be extended to other fields of application.

On the economic front, direct immediate benefits for individuals ranging from personal savings (eg in the case of mobility in which the costs can be shared) to a decrease of the cost of the energy bill (eg in the case of micro-projects on energy, alternative energy sources or energy savings), from a better quality of agricultural produce (and / or supply in case of a food subsistence system) to the improvement of the effectiveness of the results - in the presence or not of a cost reduction (eg with maintenance projects and other micro-interventions in the water sector).

In terms of systemic economic benefits, as always very difficult to estimate, there may be a “territorial marketing effect”: it is certainly more attractive to settle in a cohesive territory than in other places. A potential advantage is that an area of this type will have a greater awareness and environmental monitoring capabilities and thus attract more economic activities that look favourably on their relationship with the local context. For example, the economic activities linked to the short food supply chain or those linked to the local environmental capital (ecotourism).

Another potential long-term economic benefit is the reduction of lock-in phenomena; sharing from the bottom-up of intentions and future plans allows to detect entanglements early - before any investment is made.

Bibliography:

  • Carraro, Carlo, 2008, “Cambiamenti climatici e strategie di adattamento in Italia. Una valutazione economica” FEEM in collaboration with the Institute for Environmental Protection and Research Istituto Superiore per la Protezione e la Ricerca Ambientale - ISPRA)


EFFORTS FOR REDUCING THE PROJECT'S "CARBON FOOTPRINT"discuss (max. 10.000 characters)[edit]

Beneficiaries believe that efforts to keep the project's carbon footprint low should focus on:

  • projects management activities;
  • implementation actions;
  • content of the project.

From the management point of view the Project will adopt an internal code of conduct to reduce its carbon footprint.

As the Partners' offices are located in the same neighborhood, the project's mobility will be informed to the principle of exemplarity. Transportation will be minimized, with the exception of the trips that involve activities to be eventually carried out on European territory (exchange and visits with other networks and projects).

The use of printed information materials will be limited to essential. Regarding specific communication materials, only the parts of the Layman's report, leaflets and some posters will be printed on recycled paper.

On implementation actions, "greening clauses" will be included in procurement contracts, following the guidelines already in place (and improving them whenever possible).


Torna all'indice