A1 - Build participation and bottom-up governance mechanisms
Contents
Description and methods employed (what, how, where and when)[edit]
What[edit]
A1 includes all the activities needed to facilitate the IESS process of participation and bottom-up governance mechanism by individuating, involving and motivating stakeholders to participate in the debate. This action aims to promote dialogue, understanding and co-ordination between different actors both to individuate local vulnerabilities of involved territories and to optimise existing resources.
Citizens, businesses, environmental groups, associations and stakeholders from civil society will be invited to participate in a mixed inter-municipal Council Committee on Climate change (CCC) organised in different areas of interest, together with political and technical representatives of every municipality.
This action belongs to the A - Preparatory set of actions.
How[edit]
The action will start taking into account the existing different levels of citizens participation in the IESS municipalities, starting from the GRANT experience, where a participatory approach is already ongoing (11 Committees are operating on different political issues, from environment to urban planning, from transports to economic activities, etc.) and trying to enlarge this model to FONTA and CARMI.
A technical group of internal and external experts will be engaged to collect and summarize information about the main territorial vulnerabilities starting from existing analyses, studies and spatial planning documents (i.e. Piani di Assetto Territoriale Intercomunale, P.A.T.I. Medio Brenta e Alta Padovana) but focusing on the four themes already prioritized in the IESS agenda: water, land use, mobility and energy.
A first group of open public meetings and debates with citizens will be organised at various municipal locations in spaces open to public debate to raise awareness about climate change impacts, and mitigation and adaptation needs. In order to reach directly the highest number of citizens, a small number of voluntaries (12 "IESS promoters" or "IESS angels") selected among the local associations that have already shown interest to the project and that participated to the conceiving phase since the beginning, will be enrolled. They will visit and attend local aggregation places such us pubs, schools, sports facilities and minimarkets to explain the basic of the project giving the calendar of public meetings and inviting citizens to participate. This approach will give a personal motivation for joining and ensure that even those who do not follow the meetings have been informed.
In addition to posting the notices on the city council web sites (and IESS web site) prior to each meeting, email notices will be sent to already identified stakeholder groups and community members to invite them to attend the meetings and provide feedback. Citizens should be aware that climate change will very likely proceed for at least several decades.
During the first phase, the meetings features presentations from local and regional experts on the different adaptation topics. These presentations discuss the current state of practices (i.e. “business as usual”), the predicted impacts of climate change on the IESS area based on the best available data and scenario simulations, and the vulnerability of municipal operations and the broader community to these impacts. Experts will also estimate risk levels (where risk is defined as a product of the likelihood of the climate change impact occurring and the consequence of the impact) to each identified vulnerability. Staff summarized this information into a Climate Adaptation Planning Matrix for each focus area.
With the support of an expert facilitator, and use of questionnaires, the meetings will try to individuate resilience to climate change priorities and to start collecting information from bottom-up while at the same time informing about main relevant issues. For example for mobility issue, the meetings will try to identify the nature and spatial arrangement of current travel behaviours, focusing on journeys to and from the work place or to explore the context (physical, social, cultural, economic) for people’s perceptions, attitudes and motivations regarding their use of different travel modes.
Development and exploration of imagined future scenarios will be introduced to help participants think systemically, recognize critical uncertainties, and prioritize potential strategies and recommendations. Stakeholder discussions and agreements are will be useful for a transparent decision making process on the main objectives, criteria and their weightings for the prioritisation of climate change mitigation and adaptation options.
The emphasis on the participation process will generate a consensual strategy, both regarding the challenges faced and the tools and targets which is considered to be the only way towards a shared future. In small cities, face-to-face contacts are essential but communication and information technologies and social network may facilitate the process, engaging people of the territory into the debate. In this small territories prevails a strong community spirit and a sense of identity that should easily be fostered also through other initiatives (IESS website, initiatives with schools and local associations, see Action D4). Tweets and other social web messaging will keep all participants informed. The partnership will maintaining a public calendar of meetings.
The objective is to create different physical and virtual spaces for participants to develop strategies for action and to facilitate the emergence of new knowledge in the transformative process of retooling climate mitigation and adaptation actions to a locally based system. This co-created knowledge will be able to sustain a resilient climate change system model rooted in the unique social-ecological place of IESS Municipalities that is inclusive of their cultural and geographic diversity. Through this process new culture-level patterns of people’s goals, values, beliefs and behaviours can emerge that open up community level resilient ways of being.
Consultation is also a key driver to engage the interested parties with the objective to create and institutionalize an inter-municipal IESS Committee on Climate Change with consultative and role to support municipal officers, that will operate during the life-time of the project. The Committee will be composed by 4 different Interest groups (of about a minimum of 10 people each from civil society, associations, business operators, professionals, experts, ecc.) around a relevant issue (water, land use, mobility and energy). The CCC Interest groups will gather suggestions, alerts, proposals from the bottom through open sessions and other IESS communication channels. The CCC Interest groups will become change agents, able to affect system dynamics to change unsustainable trajectories and to influence the broader values and perceptions of citizens.
Taking into account the results of the stakeholder consultations, the Interest groups will conduct separate in-depth screening to gather also unforeseen resources owned by the citizens.
The survey will have mainly the objective of individuating resources for adaptive and mitigating mobility modes (for example, citizens who already commute will be a resource for carpooling); for experimental land use (for example, the availability of private lands that will be at disposal for the demonstration actions along with public lands), energy resources for resilience (eg availability or future energy production or adoption of energy efficiency criteria), water resources for resilience (such as the availability of reservoires or the interest to start private initiatives to safeguard water).
Methods employed:
- meetings and debates
- questionnaires
- focus groups
- factual knowledge ( “learning together to manage together”)
- scenario visioning and scenario building
- cognitive mapping
Where[edit]
This action will mainly take place in the project implementation area, i.e. IT
When[edit]
02/09/13-14/02/14
Constraints and assumptions[edit]
- Constraints
- Reliable information is available to stakeholders in a form they can understand.
- Time to participate, to build trust, to learn, to resolve disputes, to create solutions.
- Assumptions
- Willingness to learn and participate amongst stakeholders
Beneficiary responsible for implementation[edit]
The beneficiary responsible for implementation is GRANT. FONTA and CARMI participate in the action.
Expected results[edit]
The main expected results of this actions are
- more than 2500 people directely/indirectly contacted by IESS promoters
- a set of reasoned positions and indications from the main stakeholders gathered
- at least 400 peoples involved in open public debates
- 1 Climate Adaptation Planning Matrix
- 1 Climate Change Committee (with 4 Interest Groups) settled
- 1 Vulnerability map of IESS territory developed with a participative approach
- the building of a common knowledge base and a common language among stakeholders to support IESS initiatives
- the improving of access to understandable and usable information on potential resources
Indicators of progress[edit]
The main indicator is Participation. For the Participation specific indicators are among others:
- Number of citizens involved in face-to-face stakeholder consultations
- Number of open meetings organised
- Presence of a Climate change committee and Interest Groups
- Number of ongoing contacts to consultation area of the website
- Number of suggestions given through the website
- Stakeholders perceptions of levels of participation (stakeholders could be asked to pin-point levels of participation on a scale of 1-5)
For Participation thresholds are among others:
- > 400 citizens involved in face-to-face stakeholder consultations
- > 1500 contacts to consultation area of the website
- > 5 face-to-face meetings organised in the municipalities
- 1 Climate change committee settled with 4 Interest Groups (10-15 people each)
Deliverable products[edit]
- DA1.1 - Inventory of vulnerabilities and resources for mitigation, adaptation and resilience (14/02/2014)
Milestones[edit]
- M1 - Vulnerability analysis ready (22/11/2013)
- M2 - Citizen committees engaged and settled (22/11/2013)
Timetable[edit]
For each project action, please tick the corresponding Period. A1 - Build participation and bottom-up governance mechanisms 120 days? 02/09/13 -14/02/14