Talk:B2 - Enable adaptive and mitigating mobility modes
Car pooling
The average occupancy of private cars in Switzerland has decreased continuously over the past years, today it is lower than 1.62 persons per vehicle, in commuting even lower than 1.14 (1994).
Yet it is practically impossible to increase car occupancy rapidly and significantly under today's framework of the transport economy by applying partial and isolated measures. Incentive measures like co-ordinating centres for matching transportation needs, publicity campaigns, preferential parking for carpools, or reserved lanes for High Occupancy Vehicles (HOV-lanes) do not by themselves induce the formation of numerous new carpools. At best they may stop or slow down a further reduction of the car occupancy.
Such measures make sense only if they are very cheap, or if they have other positive effects, such as the acceleration of buses on separate lanes. So far it has not been possible to implement a comprehensive strategy to increase car occupancy in Europe.
In Switzerland, such a strategy would more or less interfere in many places with today's strategy of promoting public transport. The main reason for this situation is mostly the fact that operating a private car is so cheap that most workers can easily afford to drive alone. They usually prefer the flexibility of single occupancy driving to the co-ordination effort necessary to form a carpool.
Furthermore, carpool matching centres cannot operate efficiently for commuters if they have to cover their costs, because without individual assistance the number of new carpools will hardly be greater in the long run than the number of disappearing ones.
Some day, the use of internet-based information may facilitate the exchange of information on empty seats, but so far the modest success of such matching services is usually limited to occasional intercity trips. There are no lasting positive experiences available for commuting. The technology is practically ready, but it does not replace the personal contact.
Most experiments aiming at an increase of car occupancy in Europe have not shown encouraging results, except for the HOV-lanes in Madrid and in Leeds.
In order to arrive at a considerably higher occupancy, it is probably necessary to improve the economic framework for car-poolers, i.e. to have higher costs of car transport, and to induce a different public attitude towards the use of cars. Specific measures will have a considerable effect only in a subsequent phase. This does not exclude that it may make sense to introduce measures (e.g. HOV-lanes) for other specific reasons, such as congestion mitigation, and increase car occupancy at the same time.
Over the long run it is clear that any transport policy which is supposed to be sustainable has to include the use of the 60% to 80% of the car seats which are empty today, even if this means that rigorous restrictions for single occupancy driving have to be applied. An effective strategy to improve occupancy rates can only be implemented after the political debate has reached a reasonably strong consensus, that a sustainable economy with sustainable transport policies needs to be put in practice.
As long as the debate about the right way to reach sustainability (i.e. the fight between market-base policies and regulation) is going on, it is hard to promote car-pooling effectively.
Methodology When setting up the research programme on urban transport, the European Commission assumed that car occupancy can be increased by using specific measures and innovative technologies. Consequently, real life demonstrations were asked for.
The ICARO project has consisted out of three parts:
first of all, best practices and general conditions for the formation of carpools were examined in different countries of Europe; secondly, in six countries pilot projects were realised and the transferability was studied with computer simulations; thirdly, recommendations and a manual have been drafted based on these elements.